What to Ask Your Military Attorney

Facing allegations in the military, whether for misconduct, a violation of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), or administrative proceedings, is an incredibly daunting experience. Service members often find themselves uncertain about their future, overwhelmed by the complexities of military law, and unsure of how to proceed. Selecting the right military attorney and asking the right questions are crucial steps to safeguarding your career, reputation, and freedom.

This guide outlines critical questions every service member should ask their defense attorney to ensure they receive the best possible representation. It also highlights why preparation and transparency are key to achieving a favorable outcome.

Military Attorney

The Importance of Asking Questions

Military law is unique and complex, with its procedures, rules of evidence, and consequences. Civilian courts and attorneys often lack the specialized knowledge required to navigate this system effectively. Also, your assigned military lawyer often does not have the time, energy, or experience to give your case the dedication it requires.

Whether you are in the Air Force, Army, Coast Guard, Marine Corps, Navy, or Space Force, your choice of legal representation and your ability to actively participate in your defense can significantly impact the outcome of your case. By asking your attorney pointed, strategic questions, you gain insight into their expertise, approach, and commitment to your defense.

Critical Questions to Ask Your Military Attorney

1. What Is Your Experience with Cases Like Mine?

It’s vital that you have an attorney with experience in handling cases similar to yours. Ask about their track record, including the number of cases they have successfully defended and their familiarity with the charges you’re facing.

Military law encompasses a wide range of offenses, from sexual assault and drug use to insubordination and desertion. Not all military attorneys have experience with every type of case. As we say, EXPERIENCE WINS.

Why It’s Important

An attorney who has handled cases similar to yours will have a deeper understanding of the specific challenges and strategies required for success. For instance, defending against allegations of sexual misconduct requires knowledge of forensic evidence, cross-examining accusers, and leveraging expert witnesses. If your defense lawyer does not have that experience, they cannot effectively leverage it in your case.

Follow-Up Questions

  • How many cases like mine have you handled?
  • Can you provide examples of successful outcomes in similar cases?
  • Are there unique aspects of my case that require special attention?

2. How Much Time and Energy Can You Dedicate to My Case?

Military attorneys, whether assigned by the Judge Advocate General’s (JAG) Corps or a hired civilian lawyer, often juggle multiple cases at once. While this is not unusual, it’s crucial to determine whether your attorney’s workload allows them to dedicate sufficient time to your defense. A manageable caseload enables your attorney to conduct thorough investigations, analyze evidence and identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and prepare for every stage of your case, from preliminary hearings to trial.

Why It’s Important

Facing allegations in the military is one of the most stressful situations a military member can endure. The stakes are incredibly high, and the complexity of military legal proceedings requires meticulous preparation and attention to detail. An attorney who is spread too thin or lacks focus on your case may miss critical details, fail to challenge weak points in the prosecution’s case, or neglect to explore potential defenses. Asking how much time and energy your attorney can dedicate helps ensure your case receives the attention it deserves.

Follow-Up Questions

  • How many cases are you currently handling?
  • How often will we meet to discuss my case, and how will you update me on progress?
  • What steps do you take to ensure each client gets sufficient time and attention?
  • Who will be working on my case, and will any aspects be delegated to junior staff or paralegals?

3. What Are the Potential Consequences of My Case?

Military allegations can result in a wide range of consequences, from loss of rank and pay to imprisonment, dishonorable discharge, and lifelong stigma. Whether you are facing allegations of domestic violence, DUI, sexual harassment, or even sexual assault, every case is different and can have different impacts on your future. Your attorney should provide a realistic assessment of what is at stake for you and your military career.

Why It’s Important

Understanding the potential consequences helps you make informed decisions about your case. For example, a dishonorable discharge can affect your ability to find civilian employment and result in the loss of VA benefits. Similarly, a conviction for a UCMJ violation may require you to register as a sex offender.

Follow-Up Questions

  • What are the worst-case and best-case scenarios?
  • How will this affect my military career and future civilian opportunities?
  • Can you help me mitigate any collateral consequences?

4. How Long Will My Case Take?

Military legal proceedings can vary in duration, depending on the complexity of the case and the nature of the allegations. Cases take even longer when a court-martial is involved because those cases involve a military judge, jury, and the presentation of evidence at a trial. Your attorney should provide an estimated timeline and explain any factors that might cause delays.

Why It’s Important

Understanding the timeline helps you manage expectations and plan accordingly. For example, lengthy proceedings can affect your ability to return to normal duties or move forward with your career.

Follow-Up Questions

  • What is the typical timeline for cases like mine?
  • Are there ways to expedite the process?
  • How will delays affect my case?

Rules for Court Martial

5. Do You Specialize in Military Law?

Military law is distinct from civilian law. A criminal defense attorney who specializes in military law will have extensive experience with the UCMJ, military court-martial procedures, administrative hearings, and the nuances of military culture. Experience military defense counsel can identify unique legal issues in military cases that may not be typical in other criminal law matters.

Why It’s Important

Service members need an attorney who understands the unique aspects of military justice and criminal cases. For example, Article 15 hearings, separation boards, and court-martial proceedings differ significantly from civilian legal processes. An attorney who specializes in military law will also understand the potential impact of an adverse outcome on your military service, benefits, and post-service opportunities.

Follow-Up Questions

  • How many military cases have you handled?
  • How have you succeeded in military cases
  • Do you have experience with cases similar to mine?

6. What Are My Legal Options?

Understanding the options available to you is essential when facing military allegations. Depending on your case, you might face a range of proceedings, from nonjudicial punishment (NJP) to court-martial or administrative separation.

Why It’s Important

Your attorney should explain each option clearly, outlining the risks and potential outcomes. For example:

  • Accepting NJP might seem less severe but can still have long-term career consequences for military personnel.
  • Pleading guilty at a court-martial might mitigate punishment but results in a criminal conviction.
  • Fighting the charges could preserve your career but may involve significant personal and financial strain.

Follow-Up Questions

  • What are the potential outcomes for each option?
  • Do you recommend fighting the allegations or seeking a plea deal?
  • Can these charges be resolved through alternative means, such as administrative action?

7. How Will You Build My Defense?

Every successful legal defense starts with a clear strategy. Your attorney should explain how they plan to approach your case, identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s argument, and highlight evidence that supports your defense when providing you legal advice.

Why It’s Important

An attorney’s ability to articulate their defense strategy demonstrates their competence and dedication. For example, in a sexual assault case, they may focus on challenging the accuser’s credibility or proving consent. In a drug case, they might highlight procedural errors or lack of evidence.

Follow-Up Questions

  • What specific evidence do you need from me to build my defense?
  • Will you conduct independent investigations, such as interviewing witnesses or hiring expert witnesses?
  • How do you plan to counter the prosecution’s case?

8. How Will You Communicate With Me?

Effective communication is vital in any attorney-client relationship. You should know how often your attorney will update you on your case and whether they are accessible for questions or concerns.

Why It’s Important

A good attorney keeps their client informed, responds to inquiries promptly, and provides clear, honest updates about the case’s progress. Lack of communication can leave you feeling uncertain and unprepared.

Follow-Up Questions

  • How often will we meet to discuss my case?
  • What is the best way to contact you if I have questions?
  • Will you personally handle my case, or will it be delegated to someone else?

9. What Role Will I Play in My Defense?

As the accused, your involvement in your defense is critical. Your military defense attorney should outline what they need from you, such as providing evidence, identifying witnesses, or preparing for testimony.

Why It’s Important

Active participation in your defense allows you to provide critical insights, correct inaccuracies, and demonstrate to the panel or command that you are taking the allegations seriously.

Follow-Up Questions

  • What specific information or evidence do you need from me?
  • How can I prepare for testimony or cross-examination?
  • Are there ways I can assist in gathering evidence or finding witnesses?

10. Will You Use Expert Witnesses or Investigators?

Expert witnesses and private investigators can strengthen your defense by challenging the prosecution’s evidence or uncovering new information.

Why It’s Important

For example:

  • A forensic psychologist might testify about the reliability of eyewitness testimony.
  • A digital forensic expert could analyze electronic evidence to support your defense.
  • A private investigator might locate witnesses or gather evidence that was overlooked by law enforcement during the initial investigation.

Follow-Up Questions

  • Does your law office have access to qualified experts and investigators?
  • How will these professionals contribute to my defense?
  • Have you successfully used expert witnesses in similar cases before?

11. What Are Your Fees and Costs?

Experienced civilian attorneys charge for their services, especially if they have expertise in military law. Understanding the costs upfront is essential to avoid surprises later.

Why It’s Important

Transparency about fees ensures you can budget for your defense appropriately. It also allows you to assess whether the attorney’s services align with your financial situation and the seriousness of the allegations.

Follow-Up Questions

  • What is your fee structure (hourly rate, flat fee, or retainer)?
  • Are there additional costs for expert witnesses or investigations?
  • When will my payments be due, and how can I submit payment?

12. What Is Your Approach to Plea Negotiations?

In some cases, negotiating a plea agreement might be the best option. Your attorney should explain when and how they would approach plea negotiations and what you can expect.

Why It’s Important

A skilled negotiator can reduce charges, minimize penalties, or secure favorable terms. However, you should also ensure that your attorney is willing to fight for you if a plea deal is not in your best interest.

Follow-Up Questions

  • How do you decide whether to pursue a plea deal or fight the charges?
  • What is your track record with plea negotiations?
  • How will you ensure that any plea agreement is fair?

Josh Traeger

13. What Sets You Apart From Other Attorneys?

This question gives your attorney an opportunity to showcase their unique qualifications, experience, and commitment to your case.

Why It’s Important

Understanding what makes your attorney stand out helps you feel confident in your decision to hire them. It also allows you to evaluate whether their approach aligns with your needs and expectations.

Follow-Up Questions

  • How do you stay updated on changes in military law?
  • What do your previous clients say about working with you?
  • How do you handle cases where the odds seem stacked against the accused?

Conclusion: The Importance of the Right Attorney

Facing allegations in the military is a serious matter with life-altering consequences. Asking your military attorney the right questions ensures that you understand the challenges ahead and are confident in your legal representation. The answers to these questions will give you a clear picture of your attorney’s expertise, strategy, and commitment to your case.

At The Military Defense Firm, we specialize in defending service members against allegations under the UCMJ, from sexual assault and drug offenses to administrative separations and Article 15 hearings. Our experienced attorneys provide aggressive representation and personalized support to help service members achieve the best possible outcomes.

If you are facing allegations, contact us today for a free consultation. Let us protect your rights, your career, and your future.

Related Posts